By Vicky Sidler | Published 8 January 2026 at 12:00 GMT+2

Let’s start with a question.

Have you noticed how weird the internet feels lately?

You post something thoughtful. You get five likes, three of which are from accounts with no profile photo and names like “Inspiration_9385.” Comments say things like “Amazing insights!” but never refer to anything specific. Your inbox is full of bot spam, and somehow every third video recommends productivity tips from someone who has clearly never worked.

It’s not just you.

You’re walking through a digital hallway filled with echoes. And as creepy as that sounds, it gets worse. Because while you’re trying to market your business to real people, half the internet is no longer human.

According to Malwarebytes, bots now account for 51% of all internet traffic.

That’s not a theory. That’s math. And if you’ve been wondering why engagement feels hollow, now you know.

Welcome to the Dead Internet.

TL;DR:

• 51% of web traffic is bots, not humans

• Ad platforms count fake clicks as real engagement

• AI is training on AI, creating low-value content loops

• Vanity metrics are misleading your marketing decisions

• Real human connection is your best defence

👉 Need help getting your message right? Download the 5 Minute Marketing Fix.

Table of Contents:

Is Anyone Real Anymore?

In 2024, bots officially overtook humans online. Some are helpful (search engine crawlers). Many are not. Think click farms, spam bots, AI content scrapers, and comment junk.

This means that if 1,000 people visit your site this week, about 500 might not be people at all. They might be algorithms doing laps around the internet to harvest data or click ads.

It also means a chunk of your marketing budget might be burning up on activity that looks like engagement but leads to nothing. Zero humans. Zero sales. Just bots doing bot things.

This is not a fringe idea. It’s called the Dead Internet Theory, and it has gone from Reddit thread to reality check.

Welcome to the Slop Era:

Here’s where it gets messy. The internet used to be full of original content. Now, AI models like ChatGPT and others are training on content written by... other AI models.

This is called Model Collapse.

It’s like photocopying a photocopy a hundred times until all you see is grey fuzz. That’s what the internet is becoming: a fuzzy blur of recycled, keyword-stuffed content that sounds fine but means nothing.

It’s called AI slop. The technical term is “synthetic data contamination.” The practical result? You scroll through blogs, LinkedIn posts, and product descriptions and feel like you’ve already read them. Because you have. Dozens of times.

No wonder customer engagement is tanking. Your audience is tired. They’re not lazy. They’re overwhelmed by sameness.

You Are Celebrating the Wrong Numbers:

Let’s say your site has 2,000 monthly visitors. You feel great. But if 1,000 are bots, your conversion rate looks terrible, even if your actual human traffic is performing well.

That’s the trap.

Bots inflate your metrics, but not your bank balance.

Ad platforms love this because you keep paying for clicks and impressions. But who’s clicking? Who’s watching your video? Who’s commenting?

If you’ve ever hired an influencer with 100,000 followers but saw no spike in traffic or sales, there’s your answer. Some of those followers might be real. Most are probably not.

As a recent LinkedIn post put it, “In a dead internet, even vanity metrics are lying.”

So What Do You Do?

It’s not all doom. In fact, this is where smart small businesses can thrive.

Here’s what still works:

1. Create Unfakeable Content:

Bots can write. But they still struggle to speak, show, or react like humans.

• Use video.

• Use voice.

• Use images of real people doing real things.

A quick voice note to your audience is harder to fake than a polished AI article.

2. Build a Community, Not Just an Audience:

Platforms are noisy. Private groups are quiet and loyal. Use tools like:

• Circle

• Skool

• WhatsApp

• Or even email lists.

You don’t need millions. You need the right 50 people who trust you.

3. Pass the Turing Test:

Show your human side. Use real opinions. Get a little weird.

AI is built to be average. Humans aren’t.

That typo in your email? That strange metaphor in your blog? That off-script moment in your live stream? It tells people you’re real.

And in a fake internet, real is premium.

I keep telling clients this. If your content looks like a robot could’ve made it, a robot probably did. And real people will scroll right past it—just like they should.

The Cost of Confusion:

Digital fatigue isn’t your fault. It’s the side effect of an internet that has stopped making sense.

But clarity still wins. And clarity starts with knowing exactly what your business does and why it matters.

If you want a simple way to explain your value in one clear sentence, I’ve made a tool for that. Download my 5-Minute Marketing Fix and get clear.

👉 Download it free here.

Related Articles:

1. OpenAI’s $27B Loss Could Tank the Whole AI Industry

You’ve just read about Model Collapse and the flood of AI slop. This article explains the financial chaos behind it and why depending on unstable platforms could burn your business.

2. Ideal Client Profile: The Marketing Shortcut Small Businesses Miss

Wondering how to escape the “marketing to bots” trap? Start by getting laser-focused on the real humans you want to reach. This guide shows you how.

3. Influencer Marketing ROI in 2025: Why It’s Still Winning

If you’ve been burned by fake followers or hollow metrics, this one shows you how to tell the difference between real influence and inflated nonsense.

4. Use These Two Words to Instantly Improve Your Marketing

In an internet full of noise, simplicity cuts through. This article gives you a language shortcut that makes your messaging feel personal and grounded.

5. Content Marketing Boosts Revenue More Than Ads

Bot clicks are draining ad budgets. This post offers a smarter play: own your content, build trust, and generate better leads without the algorithm middleman.

Frequently Asked Questions About Bot Traffic and the Dead Internet Theory

1. What is the Dead Internet Theory?

It’s the idea that a large chunk of internet activity is now fake. Instead of real people engaging with your content, much of the traffic comes from bots, scrapers, and AI tools that mimic humans. Recent data says over 50% of all web traffic is non-human.

2. How can I tell if my website traffic is from bots?

Look at your analytics. If you see unusual spikes, high bounce rates, or traffic from weird locations or outdated browsers, bots might be visiting. Also, if you’re getting clicks but no conversions, that’s a red flag.

3. Are bots clicking on my Facebook or Google ads?

Yes, some of them are. Many ad platforms struggle to filter out bad bot traffic. While they do offer fraud protection, it’s not perfect. You could be paying for clicks that never had a chance to convert.

4. Why do some influencers have lots of followers but no engagement?

Fake followers are often bots. They inflate follower counts but don’t engage meaningfully. If an influencer gets thousands of likes but very few comments—or all the comments sound robotic—you’re likely looking at a bot-inflated account.

5. What is AI slop, and why does it matter?

AI slop is low-quality, mass-produced content made by AI tools just to fill the internet with keywords. It’s often unreadable, repetitive, or vague. The more of it that exists, the harder it is for real, helpful content to stand out.

6. What does "model collapse" mean?

Model collapse happens when AI tools train on content made by other AI tools. Over time, the quality drops because the content is just recycled noise. Think of it like photocopying a photocopy until everything turns blurry.

7. How do bots affect my marketing performance?

They mess up your data. You might think a post or ad did well because it got lots of views or clicks, but if those came from bots, they won’t convert into leads or sales. That leads to wasted budget and poor decisions.

8. How can I make sure I’m reaching real people?

Use email lists, private communities, and direct engagement tools. Platforms like Skool, WhatsApp, or even a good old newsletter are much harder for bots to fake. Also, use content that’s harder to mimic, like video and voice.

9. Should I stop advertising online?

Not necessarily, but you should advertise smarter. Set clear filters, monitor your audience quality, and focus on platforms where you can track real engagement. Combine paid ads with organic content to reduce your risk.

10. What kind of content still works in the “Dead Internet”?

Content that feels human. Video, real photos, behind-the-scenes updates, voice notes, and live sessions—these are hard for bots to fake and easy for humans to connect with. The less polished, the more trustworthy it feels.